ICO warns tech industry to rebuild public trust or face ruin

Regulator says innovation at risk of backlash akin to GM food scandal

Protesters

Society faces a massive "crisis of trust" with regards to data-driven innovation which could lead to heavy legal restrictions unless it's resolved urgently.

Public confidence is critical to advancements in a host of areas like IoT and smart cities according to the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO) executive director for technology policy and innovation Simon McDougall. Trust, he added, is especially critical to the government's national data strategy.

This is because, without trust as to how personal data is being used, shared, and processed, even the most coherent of national strategies will collapse when the public mood turns foul.

"I have to say, that as one single metric right now, we ain't doing so good. And nobody here's doing that good," he told audience members at a forum on the UK's national data strategy, held in London on Tuesday.

He added that if the ICO had established a physical dashboard showing levels of public trust there'd be "red lights blinking everywhere, klaxons blaring, various ticker tape sprawling out saying 'danger, danger'".

He was speaking directly to an audience that comprised representatives from the tech industry, and technical staff with other organisations. Attendees included BT, Fujitsu and KPMG, as well as public sector organisations HMRC and the Office for National Statistics.

"We are having a crisis of trust right now in how innovation is happening, how our data is being used," he continued. "And that is a challenge for us a regulator, this is a challenge for everybody in this room, and it's a challenge for anybody envisioning new and innovative uses of data in the future."

He added that trust slumped following a series of historic bungled government IT projects and schemes such as New Labour's confused ID cards system. But the private sector has "really driven the crisis" in the last few years, with the likes of the Cambridge Analytica and Facebook scandal.

McDougall was joined at the event by a host of speakers including chair of the digital framework task group Mark Enzer, and Roger Taylor, chair of the government's Centre for Data Ethics and Innovation.

Taylor highlighted in his comments that a failure to address ethical concerns now will be extremely damaging, but that success could lead to major benefits; adding a high-risk/high-reward dimension to any national data strategy.

He argued that one clear benefit of harnessing the power of data is the creation of a more open and accountable society.

This may seem like a strange thing to say, he added, at a time when these technologies are being associated with abuse, unethical practices, and a lack of accountability for powerful organisations like social media companies. This is in addition to how states such as China are harnessing citizens' data in authoritarian ways, like the recently-introduced social credit.

"To suggest that there is a real opportunity in terms of creating open and transparent and democratic society might seem a little counter-intuitive," said Taylor. "But it's worth just stressing that all these problems I've just described, they are all down to a common cause. And that is the power of these intelligent networks to understand how we are behaving collectively.

"That power exists. And what we have not yet really just found is a way we can harness that power in a way that is consistent with democratic values, and that is consistent with the sort of open, pluralistic society we want. But the opportunity to get that right is enormous."

As for the consequences of failing to close this trust deficit, the ICO's McDougall pointed to a 'GM foods moment' in which any potential for exploring data-driven innovation is neutered due to overwhelming public cynicism.

"We went straight from there being some initiatives and trials to there being a media outcry and the whole thing being banned. And we did not realise either the risks or opportunities of behind that because we stopped too soon."

He added that tech firms and organisations like his own must work to restore public trust in data use. If not, then initiatives such as facial recognition and sharing large datasets within the NHS, for example, risk suffering the same fate.

Featured Resources

Defeating ransomware with unified security from WatchGuard

How SMBs can defend against the onslaught of ransomware attacks

Free download

The IT expert’s guide to AI and content management

How artificial intelligence and machine learning could be critical to your business

Free download

The path to CX excellence

Four stages to thrive in the experience economy

Free download

Becoming an experience-based business

Your blueprint for a strong digital foundation

Free download

Recommended

Derq moves into Qualcomm Smart Cities Accelerator Program
smart city

Derq moves into Qualcomm Smart Cities Accelerator Program

20 Aug 2021

Most Popular

What are the pros and cons of AI?
machine learning

What are the pros and cons of AI?

8 Sep 2021
Apple patches zero-day flaw abused by infamous NSO exploit
exploits

Apple patches zero-day flaw abused by infamous NSO exploit

14 Sep 2021
Hackers develop Linux port of Cobalt Strike for new attacks
Security

Hackers develop Linux port of Cobalt Strike for new attacks

14 Sep 2021