Facebook dealt data collection blow in landmark antitrust case

Germany's top court says the social network is "abusing its dominant position" to collect excessive user data

Germany's top court has ruled that Facebook must stop merging user data on its platform with data collected from Instagram, WhatsApp, and third-party sites.

The German Federal Court of Justice backed the country's Federal Cartel Office (FCO), which last year claimed the US social media giant abuses its market dominance to collect excessive user data.

“Facebook can, in future, no longer force its users to agree to effectively endless collection and collation of non-Facebook data,” said Andreas Mundt, head of the FCO, in 2019.

“If the user does not grant permission, Facebook may not exclude them from its services and must forgo merging the collection and collation of data from various sources.”

"There are no serious doubts about Facebook's dominant position in the German social media network market, or that Facebook is abusing its dominant position with the terms of use prohibited by the Federal Cartel Office," the court found.

“[Facebook] abuses its position by – contrary to the GDPR [data protection] rules – making the private use of its network dependent on its power to link user data with personal data created by using Facebook itself,” the court ruled.

Overturning an earlier ruling that had suspended enforcement of a ban on Facebook merging user data, the court said that Facebook needed explicit users' consent before it can combine their Facebook data with the data from other sources, including Instagram and WhatsApp.

It added that the company must comply with the order while its appeal against an earlier ruling is pending in a lower court.

Facebook’s European headquarters in Dublin has four months to respond to the decision and must explain how it plans to ask its users for permission to collect their data.

Related Resource

Feeding the content-data loop

Like data, content must be well-managed, trustworthy, and secure

Download now

“Today’s decision relates to the preliminary proceedings on the stay order,” a Facebook spokesperson said in a statement. “The main proceedings, before the court of appeals, are ongoing and we will continue to defend our position that there is no antitrust abuse.”

Tuesday's ruling, which deals a major blow to Facebook's business model, could have wider ramifications for the social network, as Germany's landmark decision to explore whether data dominance is an antitrust issue could encourage other countries to follow suit.

Last year, it was revealed that two-thirds of the Irish Data Protection Commission's (DPC) ongoing investigations into multinational tech firms concern Facebook, and its subsidiaries WhatsApp and Instagram.

Featured Resources

The challenge of securing the remote working employee

The IT Pro Guide to Sase and successful digital transformation

Free Download

VMware Cloud workload migration tools

Cloud migration types, phases, and strategies

Free download

Practices for maximising the business value of digital infrastructure Consumption-as- a-Service subscriptions

IDC PeerScape

Free Download

Container network security guide for dummies

Enforcing Kubernetes best practices

Free download

Recommended

Senator wants social media companies held liable for spreading anti-vax lies
social media

Senator wants social media companies held liable for spreading anti-vax lies

23 Jul 2021

Most Popular

How to move Microsoft's Windows 11 from a hard drive to an SSD
Microsoft Windows

How to move Microsoft's Windows 11 from a hard drive to an SSD

4 Jan 2022
Microsoft Exchange servers break thanks to 'Y2K22' bug
email delivery

Microsoft Exchange servers break thanks to 'Y2K22' bug

4 Jan 2022
Solving cyber security's diversity problem
Careers & training

Solving cyber security's diversity problem

5 Jan 2022